Loyalty is good and loyalty is important, but loyalty can be taken too far. Loyalty goes from being an asset to a liability as soon as our party starts to triumph over our principles. When we hold our friends to a different standard than our perceived enemies. When winning must come at any cost.
Right now as Americans, we are living in a highly polarized age. It can feel like every battle we are in is a life or death situation. It feels like a war, and from a Christian perspective it is a war and always has been. But often in war, the lines between right and wrong can get smudged. Obviously, this should never happen to those who are fighting in a war of good and evil on the side of good. Yet sadly, it often can.
This issue came to light to me in a new way recently. It’s a story I don’t relish discussing, and so I’m going to be intentionally vague. Some of you will likely know exactly what I’m talking about, and if you don’t all you have to do is copy and paste my description of this situation into an AI model and they’ll know exactly what I’m talking about. A prominent antagonist of evangelical Christianity recently accused a prominent Christian thought leader of plagiarism. This is sad, and I hope that it is not true, but what was equally sad to me was the way many people responded. Not all responses were bad, but I think some were. So how did people respond?
1. I Didn’t Have Time to Look into It
Honestly, no problem with people who say this. There are lots of crises happening all the time all around the world, and for many people a potential plagiarism scandal doesn’t rank very high on the list. No problem. My only caution would be to those who add to this statement a “but…” If you haven’t had time to look into that, fair enough. But don’t give a hot take, especially publicly, if you admit you don’t really know what’s going on.
2. Do We Have All the Evidence?
This is another response I find totally valid. No, we don’t have all the evidence yet. The Bible warns that if we answer a matter before we have all the facts, we are foolish. We should wait until we have heard a clear and cogent explanation, or a sincere and humble apology. Unfortunately, in this case there was a response video that was taken down shortly after it was put up. I haven’t seen it, because it is now private, but from what I gather it was neither a clear explanation or a sincere and full apology. Having said that, we are wise to wait until more facts come out over the days and weeks ahead. At the same time, more accusations and evidence has been presented even in the last few days, and it’s fair at this point to at least say that what has come out and what has been alleged is at the very least concerning.
3. Is It Really That Big a Deal?
Some don’t think the charge of plagiarism is that serious a charge. Especially those who have not been in academic settings may wonder why it matters that everything be properly cited. Others are charitably hoping for the best and wondering if what is going on is simply sloppy citation. Maybe a source was not sufficiently altered or a footnote was left out here or there. Still others will say it was a long time ago, or that it was only for papers for a master’s degree and not for a published, peer-reviewed article.
In response to these criticisms, which are varied but share a common thread, let me make the following observations. Yes, plagiarism is serious because in the academic world today it is considered a kind of intellectual theft. Plagiarism takes the hard work of someone else and passes it off as one’s own. It is theoretically possible that a group could all agree that plagiarism isn’t that serious, and then within that group it would not be wrong. But this is not the world that we live in. If the culture considers something theft, Christians should have nothing to do with it. As for the charges, they are more serious than sloppy citations. The initial claim was substantial borrowing of a source that was not cited once in the paper. Other charges have continued to come forward.
The defense that was made in response argued that, while this paper was uploaded to a site designed for scholars to share their work, it was never turned in for credit and that it was just a rough draft. Frankly, that seems odd. I’m not saying it was a lie, but it does just seem really odd. It was also claimed that this represented an older version of the apologist, with the implication that he had grown now and didn’t do this sort of thing. Perhaps that is true, but if plagiarism was an issue when he completed his master’s degree, that raises questions about the legitimacy of the degree. Furthermore, there are accusations that plagiarism has continued. Again, we should wait for more evidence, but the charges here are serious if true. This is not something that can be lightly brushed off.
4. This Is Badly Motivated, So We Don’t Need to Worry About It
This is the most concerning response that I have seen, and is honestly the main concern behind this brief post. Many people wrote off the accusation as soon as they saw who was making it. “All you need to know is that …. Is the one making this charge,” some said. Well, no. I’m sorry but no. That is not all you need to know. Can you imagine if someone made a credible accusation with evidence that a pastor was cheating on his wife, and the response was “Yeah, but that guy is a critic of the church”? If these accusations are true, they are serious, and we need to be honest about it.
Part of my frustration and disappointment is that we recently saw this play out, but in reverse. Not too long ago the president of Harvard stepped down from her role because there was substantial evidence that she had plagiarized. At first, many tried to argue she should keep her job, because the people who pointed out the plagiarism were just out to get her. Were they out to get her? Yeah, in a sense they were. But they were also correct in pointing out the plagiarism. The political right was quite upset about the weak defense being made, and rightly so. It’s been somewhat surreal to see the same argument being made for those who want to see the God of truth and right prevail.
Of course, none of this is to say that the team you are on doesn’t matter, or that you shouldn’t be on a team at all. We need to surround ourselves with people who have the same goals, the same values, and are fighting for the same cause. And yes, there will be pointless, petty snipes that come at us from enemies of the cross, and we must stand firm through those. But we cannot allow our friendships and partnerships to make us overlook serious accusations. Yes, wait for the information to come in, but don’t make defenses before you know the facts. And don’t throw out the charges because you don’t like the one making the charges. If the cause of God’s truth is going to prevail, we have to be committed to truth and accuracy. Even if it costs us in the short run.
Discover more from Proclaim & Defend
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.